When I get angry I shake uncontrollably… sometimes I’m afraid I’m going to explode into a hulk-like monster when I do this. But it takes a certain type of thing to make me that angry, and as I read the LSU Reveille today- it happened. There was an article about why Planned Parenthood should receive government funding, and the “arguments” not only pissed me off, they turned my stomach. Let’s take a look:
1. By the regulations put in by federal law, Planned Parenthood can’t put any of their government funding into abortion services because it isn’t considered to be family planning.
This is strangely worded to begin with, but I’m guessing she means that they aren’t allowed to pay for abortions with federal money. And this is true, but it is also a mere technicality. In 2011 (the most recent numbers available), federal taxpayers were forced to give Planned Parenthood $524,000,000 which accounts for nearly half of their total budget and doesn’t include state tax dollars given to regional Planned Parenthood affiliates. With about half of their revenue coming from tax dollars, we are indirectly subsidizing abortion, even if the money isn’t going to directly going to pay for them. It is just a bait and switch argument. If it wasn’t for this funding, they wouldn’t be able to operate the clinics, or hire the doctors that perform the abortions.
2. Only three percent of all the services it (Planned Parenthood) provides are abortion.
Pro-aborts LOVE this argument, and never bother to examine how Planned Parenthood came up with this number. They did it by counting every single little thing they do as a separate “service.” Let’s look at one appointment and find see how many services we can count using Planned Parenthood counting. You walk in and get a pregnancy test, 1 service. Since you’re sexually active, they recommend you get an STD test too- that’s another service, now we are up to 2. The doctor asks you if you are on the pill and if you’re happy with the type you are on- that’s “birth control counseling” and the count is 3. The doctor does a pelvic exam and pap smear- 2 more services, now you’re at 5. Finally as you walk out the door, he gives you 5 condoms, and each one is counted as a service. So that is 10 services at one appointment. They do the same thing with counting the abortion process. Legally, you must take a pregnancy test, receive counseling and view an ultrasound prior to getting an abortion; Planned Parenthood counts each of those as an individual service, and not as part of their abortion services.
Additionally, a lawsuit recently settled by Planned Parenthood in Texas resulted in them paying the Texas Government over $4 million for charging state Medicaid for services that were never rendered, meaning that they falsified the number of services provided.
The 3% number is clearly false, so let’s look at some other numbers:
- 1 in 4 abortions in America are performed at a Planned Parenthood clinic or affiliates
- Planned Parenthood performed 915 abortions per day
- 92% of pregnant women who go into a Planned Parenthood get an abortion
- Planned Parenthood does 391 abortions for each adoption referral it provides
- In 2011, Planned Parenthood made $150,000,000 in profit on abortion procedures.
- There are over 8,000 community health centers that provide low cost healthcare without profit from abortions.
3. Conservative government officials, mostly men, are the ones trying to take away these fundamental and essential care options.
Ah, the classic pro-lifers are mostly men argument. While pro-life elected officials are mostly male, the same is true of pro-abortion elected officials, and elected officials in general. Women make up over 50% of the voting public but hold less than 5% of elected offices. So the governmental argument is non-unique to the pro-life side of the argument.
But if you look at who the leaders of the pro-life movement you’ll see that it is mostly women! Some examples include women such as Abby Johnson, Live Action’s Lila Rose, Charmaine Yoest who is President of Americans United for Life, Carol Tobias who is President of National Right to Life, Marjorie Dannenfelser who is President of SBA List, Concerned Women for America, and Alveda King, the niece of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Oh and not that I’m in the same league as these amazing women, but last time I checked I was a woman. I’ve been to my share of pro-life meetings, lectures, and events, and in my experience women almost always outnumber the men by a large number.
Additionally, the last time Gallup did a study on abortion views, an equal percentage of men and women polled said that they believed abortion was “morally wrong”. 51% of both genders agreed on this. Furthermore, 5% more women than men felt that abortion should be illegal in all circumstances. Nearly a quarter of all women polled would be in favor of making abortion illegal in all cases. Recent polls on Pain Capable Abortion Bans show that actually women support these bans by a significant majority.
4. All abortion arguments and stances aside, here is the cold truth about them: unless you’re the person getting the abortion, abortions don’t affect you. Read that again, because few people understand this concept.
This is the same “logic” as the oft repeated line “Don’t like abortions, don’t have one” and is laughable at best. Martin Luther King told us that “injustice anywhere is an affront to justice everywhere,” and we see the truth of that in many of history’s greatest movements.
Take slavery for example- William Wilberforce was a member of British Parliament who was decidated to ending the slave trade, would you tell him “don’t like slavery, don’t own slaves”? Slavery didn’t directly affect him, but his heart broke for his fellow humans and the atrocities that were being perpetuated against them. The rallying cry for British abolitionists was “Am I not a man and brother?”. I ask the same question- if I see a travesty occurring at my neighbor’s home am I supposed to ignore it? What about other things that don’t affect Americans- genocides in other countries and natural disasters that occur overseas? Should we have ignored the Holocaust? Should we ignore Joseph Kony and his indentured army of enslaved child soldiers? Should we keep our money for ourselves next time a tsunami kills and displaces millions of people in another country? Of course not! Because Dr. King was right, “injustice anywhere is an affront to justice everywhere”.
5. You may love babies and you may think that taking away a person’s right to “kill” said “baby” is making the world a better place, but the only real thing you’re doing it using your hate and narrow- minded belief about the sanctity of life to dictate someone else’s.
Honestly, this one just confused me… how is it hateful to protect vulnerable human life? It seems infinitely more hateful to me, to rip a baby apart piece by piece and then vacuum it out of the womb. Because that is the reality of abortion.
Oh wait, I called it a baby, not a “baby”. I’m guessing the author would rather you call the preborn child a fetus. Which is fine because fetus is just Latin for “offspring according to its kind” and our kind, humans, call our offspring babies… so fetus pretty much means baby.
I suppose “the narrow-minded” claim could be truthful, but it’s not a bad thing. Abortion abolititionist Greg Koukl sums it up clearly: “If the unborn is not a human person, no justification for abortion is necessary. However, if the unborn is a human person, no justification for abortion is adequate.”
I could write a whole different article on scientific facts regarding fetal development, but a picture I took at a protest in San Antonio this summer handles it pretty well. The guy holding it was a member of the group Secular Pro-Life, a group of atheist and agnostic pro-lifers. Here’s the picture:
And finally, the part that truly pissed me off:
6. People in favor of defunding this wonderful service need to look past the silly three percent of abortion services and see the bigger picture.
There is nothing SILLY about abortion. Most pro-abortion advocates will admit that, and say that it is a very difficult decision. This author disagrees. She thinks that 333,964 innocent, helpless, vulnerable human beings being killed is SILLY. There are no words to accurately describe the disgust I feel when I read her sentence. 333,964 human beings. 333,964 voices silenced. I won’t ignore that. I won’t “look past” it.
I AM THE PROLIFE GENERATION!
“We will not stand down. We will expose injustice. We will fight against the lies told to our generation. We will face persecution. We will help those facing crisis. We will fight against a third of our generation being taken out before they are born. We will not be silent. We will not back down until abortion is abolished.”
–Students for Life of America